A-League preview: Melbourne City v Brisbane Roar

Reigning A-League champions Brisbane Roar have fallen behind in the race for a top-six finish and face a crucial showdown away to direct rivals Melbourne City in the match of the round on Saturday night.

When: Saturday, 28 March 2015

Where: AAMI Park, Melbourne

Kick-Off: 7:30 PM (AEDT)


Melbourne City FC: 1.Andrew REDMAYNE (GK), 5.Erik PAARTALU, 7.Iain RAMSAY, 8.Massimo MURDOCCA, 9.Harry NOVILLO, 10.Robert KOREN, 13.Jonatan GERMANO, 14.James BROWN, 15.David WILLIAMS, 16. Josh KENNEDY, 17.Jason HOFFMAN, 18.Paulo RETRE, 20.Tando VELAPHI (GK), 22.Jack CLISBY, 23.Mate DUGANDZIC, 24.Patrick KISNORBO (c), 26.Marc MARINO, 27.Kew JALIENS

Brisbane Roar FC: 2.Jerome POLENZ, 3.Shane STEFANUTTO, 4.Adam SAROTA, 6.George LAMBADARIDIS, 8.Steven LUSTICA, 9.ANDRIJA Kaluderovic, 12.Jean Carlos SOLORZANO, 16.Devante CLUT, 18.Luke BRATTAN, 19.Jack HINGERT, 21.Jamie YOUNG (gk), 23.Dimitri PETRATOS, 26.Lachlan JACKSON, 28.Brandon BORRELLO, 34.Shannon BRADY, 36.Fraser CHALMERS (gk)

Hashtag #MCYvBRI


TV - Live and exclusive coverage on FOX SPORTS 505 from 7.00pm (AEDT)

Radio - 774 ABC Melbourne, ABC Local Radio VIC, Grandstand Digital (Melbourne, Adelaide, Perth), Online / ABC Radio Mobile phone app.

Referee - Kris Griffiths-Jones


It could be now or never for title-holders Brisbane Roar if they want to defend their crown in the 2014-15 finals series.

The Queensland side are five points behind sixth-placed Melbourne City and although they still have one game in hand on John van 't Schip's men, should they lose this one, it would take a major collapse from the incumbents over the final weeks of the campaign for the Roar to sneak back in.

Brisbane's cause has not been helped by the international break. The champions are without Socceroos Matt McKay and Luke DeVere and Olyroos James Donachie and Corey Brown. 

With first-choice goalkeeper Michael Theo still injured and centre-back Jade North to miss Saturday's match with a groin problem, the visitors' backline will be paper thin at AAMI Park.

On Wednesday Frans Thijssen used holding midfielder Luke Brattan in central defence at home to the Western Sydney Wanderers, who romped to a 4-1 win despite having not previously triumphed on the road this term.

City will be licking their lips at the prospect of facing such a wounded animal, particularly given the hosts will get back three key forwards in Harry Novillo, David Williams and Josh Kennedy.

Van 't Schip is also contending with a lengthy list of absentees - Connor Chapman is suspended, Damien Duff is out for the season, while Robbie Wielaert, Jacob Melling and Ben Garuccio are all injured.

The international break has been less costly to City though, with mid-season Singaporean recruit Safuwan Baharudin and midfielder Aaron Mooy, with the Socceroos in Europe, the only missing personnel.


- Melbourne City have won three of their last four against Brisbane, losing the other.

- The Roar have lost each of their last four away games against Melbourne City, failing to score in the last two.

- None of the last eight games between these two has ended in a draw (five wins for City, three for Roar).

- City are unbeaten in seven league matches at AAMI Park, a run which began with a win over the Roar (W5 D2).

- John van 't Schip's side have conceded just three goals in that run of games and never more than once in any of those games.


Van 't Schip started with Robert Koren, Mate Dugandzic and James Brown in attacking positions last time out. 

Will that trio keep their spots or could we see any of Williams, Kennedy and Novillo come back into the starting XI? 

Whichever combination the boss goes with, they will be expected to break down Brisbane's makeshift rearguard with relative ease.

Given their weaknesses at the back, attack may be the best form of defence for the Roar. 

Matt McKay's energy in midfield will be missed, while they must also make do without Henrique's goals and the creativity of Thomas Broich. 

That leaves Jean Carlos Solorzano, Andrija Kaluderovic, Brandon Borrello and Dimitri Petratos to get the job done up front.


James Brown's winner in the surprise 1-0 victory away to Sydney FC last Friday was his first goal since netting six times for Gold Coast United in 2011-12. 

Can he retain his place and hit the back of the net again this weekend?


Melbourne City: WWLLW

City have won three of their last five, beating Sydney 1-0 away, the Newcastle Jets 4-0 and Adelaide 3-1, both of those at home. 

Sandwiched in between were successive away defeats, 3-2 at Western Sydney and 1-0 at Central Coast, results which had threatened to derail their finals challenge.

Brisbane Roar: LLLWD

It's been a shocking run for the champions, who had lost their last three in succession, 4-1 at home to Western Sydney, 2-1 at home to Wellington Phoenix and 5-4 away to Sydney FC. That's 11 goals conceded in just three matches.


Brisbane Roar have never kept a clean sheet away to Melbourne City (six games).


Melbourne City 3-1 Brisbane Roar

They very rarely make life easy for themselves, but surely this weekend City can seize a golden opportunity to deal a hammer blow to the hopes of their weakened rivals.

Fail to do so and familiar, pointed questions about the mentality of van 't Schip's men will asked yet again.

1 comment


Cant say I disagree with that proposed scoreline. Wish I could but I can't. What is likely to make it even more galling is that it is likely to be yet another of our Roar poached players who will score the winner(s) against us in Williams.