Wayne Rooney vs Bobby Charlton: who really has the best England scoring record?

The current England skipper is closing in on Sir Bobby's goal tallies for both club and country – but which player's achievements are most impressive for England? Matt Allen investigates...

These are landmark days for Wayne Rooney. Now in his 10th year at Manchester United and still seemingly an integral part of Louis van Gaal's attacking corps at Old Trafford, the Croxteth-born 'street-baller' is now England captain. Yet there has been much discussion about his career in recent weeks, from both media and supporters alike. 
 
Many national reporters have analysed his achievements so far and, almost as importantly, considered whether the player has lived up to his potential. Meanwhile, the punters at Old Trafford have recently witnessed both the good and the bad of his game – a goal against West Ham was promptly followed by a red card for a frustrated swing of a boot at Stewart Downing in the same match.
 
Some of this debate has even come from Rooney himself. When Jonathan Northcroft of The Telegraph recently asked him, flat out, whether he'd matched the status that accompanied his spectacular emergence in 2002, the striker, who soon turns 29, replied: "I still believe I can get better as a footballer. In the next three to five years you will see me as a different player. 
 
"The next two or three could be the best years of my career. I’m at a stage, especially after playing at this club for 10 years, where I’ve picked up a lot about the game. I’ve learnt. I now know exactly what I want to do on the pitch and I’m fit and ready to do it."
 
Interestingly there is an awareness of age and the heights to which he can operate in his next phase. In the same interview, Rooney spoke of Alan Shearer and how, with his legs slowing and his career reaching the flushes of autumn, the former England talisman still managed 150 goals after his 29th birthday.

Beating Bobby

If Rooney was to match that achievement, there would be some serious rewriting of the record books. For starters, Sir Bobby Charlton's Manchester United goalscoring stats (249) are within range – Rooney is only 30 behind – but it's on the international stage where he can really make his mark. For England, Sir Bobby scored 49 goals in 106 appearances between the years of 1958 and 1970. Rooney already has 41 in 97 games. It's very much there for the taking, and he knows it.
 
''I'd be a fool if I didn't look at Sir Bobby Charlton's record and feel capable of passing him," he said when pushed on the subject during the last round of England internationals. "It's in my sights. I want to do it. Hopefully one day I can.
 
"Both records have stood for a long time, and a lot of players have attempted to break them. Now they're in touching distance, the two of them. It's something I'd love to do. I feel I'm capable of doing it. Hopefully one day I'll hold the two records. I'm confident that I can."
 
With forthcoming fixtures against San Marino, Estonia, Slovenia and Scotland, there's every chance Rooney will make big inroads towards the landmark figure by the end of the year. And with several years of future international football to come, he could conceivably extend it further, and by some margin. 
 

Typically, as with everything Rooney, there will be the inevitable talk that his goals haven't stacked up against Sir Bobby's; that the opposition was better in "those days"; that England play too many fixtures in the modern game, and, well, Rooney hasn't won a World Cup (or even impressed at one, for that matter).

But are those accusations actually fair? After all, every movement he makes is endlessly analysed, while Sir Bobby was scrutinised less so during his playing career mainly due to the fact that there was no Sky Sports News, MUTV nor Twitter experts mulling over his every step. Yes, Sir Bobby won the 1966 World Cup, but in a team surrounded by gifted individuals. In recent years, Rooney has played in a team considerably less talented than that of '66 or indeed '70.
 
To settle the debate then, how about we take a statistical look at the story so far: Charlton's 49 goals – how and where they were scored, and under what circumstances – before stacking them up against Rooney's. That should settle the debate once and for all, right?
 
And before we go on, what follows is a simple comparison of stats and is in no way an assessment of tactical deployment, versatility, quality of footballer, strengths, weaknesses, duff games and so on. Just so you know, before you start tweeting furiously at us...
 
(All stats from Englandstats.com)

1) Tournament qualifiers

Wayne Rooney: 42 apps (23 goals); 1 goal every 1.83 games
Bobby Charlton: 19 (12); 1 goal every 1.58 games
 
There's a widely held belief among football fans that modern international football is a monetary merry-go-round of fixtures designed to drum up cash for associations who are in debt to builders and stadium architects (that'll be ours, then). And while there's certainly more than enough games to incur the wrath of domestic gaffers, the number of ties has hardly increased – in 1963, for example, England played nine matches over a calendar year; the same as in 2011.
 
It's the importance of the games that's changed. Both those sample years were ones without a major tournament, yet in 1963 England played eight friendlies, of which four were of the old Home Championship, plus one European Championship qualifier against France. In 2011 there were five qualifiers, plus friendlies against the likes of Spain and Sweden.
 
The point is this: England now play more fixtures of significance (depending on how you view their qualifying pools) and Rooney has competed in far more pressurised games. And he's stepped up too, scoring a goal every 1.83 matches for over 50% of his total tally. Likewise with Charlton, when England were called upon to qualify, though he delivered with even greater regularity – a goal every 1.58 games.
 
Again the devil is in the detail: Charlton played 1710 minutes in qualifying; Rooney 3354. Charlton scored every 142.5 minutes; Rooney, 145.8. There's not a lot between them.
 
An interesting footnote: between 1966 and 1968, the British Home Championship was used to determine progression to the European Championship's second round, so the six games Charlton played during that time are counted as qualifying fixtures here; he scored three goals.
 

Charlton celebrates after scoring past Scotland in 1965

VERDICT: Charlton's goals-to-game and minutes-per-goal ratios are excellent. While Rooney missed a chunk of playing time due to substitutions (or, as in the game against Montenegro, a red card), playing 3354 minutes out of an approximate 3780 (89%), it's not quite enough to give him any extra leeway.

 

Pages