Rooney returns to mixed reception

LONDON - Wayne Rooney made his return for Manchester United as they beat nine-man Wigan Athletic 2-0 on Saturday to capitalise on defeats for Premier league title rivals Chelsea and Arsenal that left their managers baffled.

Goals by Patrice Evra and Javier Hernandez put United level on 28 points with leaders Chelsea who lost consecutive league games for the first time in more than four years, going down 1-0 at Birmingham City who scored with their only effort on target.

GEAR: Kitbag's Christmas Shop now open. Save 10% on shirts, boots, balls & equipment

Arsenal wasted the chance to go top in the early game when they blew a two-goal lead against Tottenham Hotspur to lose 3-2 at Emirates Stadium. The Gunners, who had not lost at home in the league to their arch-rivals since 1993, are third on 26 points.

Dark horses Bolton Wanderers are fourth with 22 points, above Manchester City and Spurs on goal difference, after thrashing Newcastle United 5-1. City visit Fulham on Sunday.

Rooney got a mixed reception from the Old Trafford fans when he came on in the second half to make his first appearance since signing a lucrative new contract in October after stating he wanted to leave the club because it did not match his ambition.

The England striker, who has since been recovering from an ankle injury in Dubai, looked lively but was unable to get on the scoresheet despite Wigan losing Antolin Alcaraz and Hugo Rodallega to red cards in quick succession after an hour.

Evra headed United in front from Park Ji-sung's cross on the stroke of half-time and Hernandez, who also came off the bench, sealed the points with another header after 77 minutes.


In the dying moments, Rooney scuffed an effort straight at Wigan goalkeeper Ali Al Habsi while Evra inexplicably fired wide from the angle of the six-yard box.

Rooney also went close with a header as he searched in vain for his first United goal from open play this season.

"We are yet to hit our best form and normally we do that in the second half of the season so that can't come soon enough," Sir Alex Ferguson, whose side are still unbeaten in the league this season, told Sky Sports.

"Wayne got a great reception, that was very satisfying. It has taken a lot of pressure off him."

Lee Bowyer's goal lifted Birmingham out of the bottom three and completed a terrible week for champions Chelsea, who lost 3-0 at home to Sunderland last week and are struggling without injured skipper John Terry.

Bowyer scored after 17 minutes and despite intense pressure the visitors were unable to reply as Birmingham held on for their first home win against Chelsea since 1980.

"It was a good reaction from us, there was a good spirit a good attitude," surprisingly upbeat Chelsea manager Carlo Ancelotti said. "We deserved to win today, just like we deserved to lose last week against Sunderland. That's football."


Arsene Wenger was at a loss to explain Arsenal's lunchtime capitulation against Tottenham - their third home league defeat of the season - after they seemed poised to go top.

Younes Kaboul completed a remarkable comeback for Tottenham with an 86th minute headed winner after goals from Samir Nasri and Marouane Chamakh had given Arsenal a 2-0 interval lead.

Gareth Bale halved the deficit five minutes into the second period and a Rafael van der Vaart penalty, after Arsenal skipper Cesc Fabregas handled his free kick, levelled it up before defender Kaboul's late glancing header left Arsenal stunned.

"If you look at the stats and numbers, it is very difficult to understand how we lost this game - a drop in concentration, some basic errors, some bad luck as well," Wenger told the BBC.

"You are a bit speechless to re-analyse the game. It is a mystery how you can lose a game like that."

Wolverhampton Wanderers remained second from bottom after a 2-1 defeat by Blackpool while Stoke City won 3-0 at West Bromwich Albion.

Bottom club West Ham United's survival prospects also look bleak after they were thrashed 3-0 at Liverpool, for whom Glen Johnson scored the opening goal against his former club.