Balotelli is on the verge of joining the English giants from Milan for a reported fee of £16 million.
And while McAllister, who won five trophies at Liverpool towards the end of his glittering career, acknowledges the fee is not high for a player of Balotelli's calibre, but is worried about the potential for a dressing room split.
Balotelli courted regular controversy during an incident-packed spell at Manchester City prior to his return to Italy, and McAllister is not convinced the move is a good one for his former side.
"It will split everyone," McAllister told talkSPORT.
"He's got great ability, but Liverpool are very much together under Brendan Rodgers and it doesn't take a lot to split a dressing room.
"That's my only fear. I'm not so sure [about the move].
"Look at his moves – he's had great opportunities at big clubs and that fee keeps dropping and dropping.
"It's not a great deal of money in today's game, but it will split a lot of people."
McAllister also thinks Balotelli's arrival could cause a selection headache for Rodgers and potentially disrupt star striker Daniel Sturridge.
"I don't know where Balotelli plays [at Liverpool]," he added.
"If he plays up top, does Sturridge move to the side? I don't think he likes it out there.
"He [Balotelli] is not going to be second fiddle – that's not his thing.
"I'm looking forward to seeing how they line up with the three or four really attacking players they've got."
Get the best features, fun and footballing frolics straight to your inbox every week.
Thank you for signing up to Four Four Two. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.