Walcott, 19 at the time of the 2008 Zagreb game, was picked ahead of David Beckham and destroyed Croatia with his pace and finishing and showed why then-coach Sven-Goran Eriksson plucked him from obscurity for his World Cup squad two years earlier.
GEAR:Get your Arsenal shirt with Walcott printed on the back here and save 10%
A maddening failure to deliver an accurate cross, and a seemingly uncanny ability to take the wrong option when galloping clear, contributed to England coach Fabio Capello's decision to leave him out of the 2010 World Cup squad.
The Italian recalled Walcott for this month's friendly against Hungary and though he did not exactly light up Wembley he will have been buoyed, if a little confused, to be back in favour so soon.
Capello would have been delighted by Walcott's display on Saturday as he inspired Arsenal, although they were aided by the sending-off of visiting defender Ian Evatt after 31 minutes when the score was 1-0.
"For that third goal, his running off the ball, his control and his finish, I've not seen a better goal by an English player in recent years and that is exactly what we have been expecting ever since we saw him as a youngster," former Arsenal and England defender Martin Keown told BBC radio.
"This is the best I've seen Theo Walcott play. Now he needs to show he's not content with this and push on and keep trying to get better.
"His decision-making today stood out -- he did the things we expected to see him doing two years ago so clearly (manager) Arsene Wenger is getting the message across."
"What was pleasing today with Theo was he made right decisions in the final third and was calm in front of goal," said the Frenchman.
"He could finish but also give final balls. That shows he has improved.
"I never had a doubt about it. He's an intel
