Cristiano Ronaldo is far from the GOAT, but his story is more fascinating than that of Lionel Messi

Cristiano Ronaldo of Portugal looks on
Why do so many people seem to prefer Cristiano Ronaldo, but acknowledge Lionel Messi as the GOAT? (Image credit: Omar Vega/Getty Images))

Cristiano Ronaldo is one of the most bizarre stories in football history. The Portuguese maestro has, in many ways, transcended beyond being just a player, or even a person.

He is a brand, and, above all else, a symbol to the many, many fans that flock to support him in whatever he does, wherever he goes.

If you ask football fans who they believe is the GOAT, then Lionel Messi will, nine times out of ten, be the response. But what's strange is that, the more you probe, it becomes clear that many of those people believe Messi is better, but they prefer Ronaldo. Why is that?

Latest Videos From

Cristiano Ronaldo isn't the GOAT, but his story will be remembered with more fascination than that of Lionel Messi

Cristiano Ronaldo #7 of Portugal celebrates scoring his team's first goal during the FIFA World Cup 2026 Group K match between Portugal and Uzbekistan at Houston Stadium

Cristiano Ronaldo is the most fascinating figure in football history. (Image credit: Getty Images)

There's something about the Ronaldo story that, no matter how you spin it, is much more fascinating than that of his Argentine rival.

Often times, that's attributed to the classic 'Natural Talent vs Work Ethic' argument - that Ronaldo is what anyone can be if they are committed enough, while Messi is merely a one-off anomaly.

Lionel Messi during Argentina vs Austria at World Cup 2026

Lionel Messi is outperforming Ronaldo once again at the 2026 World Cup. (Image credit: Getty Images)

But honest football fans know that isn't true - no calibre of work ethic can magically make your vertical akin to that of an NBA player.

Finishing and ball-striking at the level that Ronaldo, perhaps the most varied goalscorer in football history, displayed... that cannot be etched into just anyone.

But there is a sense that Ronaldo was the more disadvantaged of the pair. Whether that's his own fault - the arrogance he displayed across his career is beyond that of a more timid Messi, and opened the Portuguese winger up to more scathing media treatment - is irrelevant.

At times, it does appear that his greatest rival didn't go through half as many tests as the #7 did.

Whether that's his lack of a Premier League resume, or the fact that the Argentine struggled in his only stint away from his beloved Barcelona, even with Neymar and Mbappe beside him.

Cristiano Ronaldo with a finger to his lips.

Cristiano Ronaldo's story will end with a man left wanting. (Image credit: PA Images)

Aside from early international failures, it seems that Messi got everything he craved, whereas Ronaldo will be left wanting.

Isn't it easier to picture the tragic tale of Ronaldo being remembered more than that of the man who... just won it all? With no real holes in his resume to dissect decades from now?

No, that doesn't seem right. It isn't a clear enough answer as to why so many people seem to prefer Ronaldo, even when they know Messi is the superior player.

Is it his personality? After all, this is a man who was caught on camera sulking after his Real Madrid team-mate nicked a back-post tap-in from him, walking off, head down, as his pals celebrated.

Is there a fascination with Ronaldo because of how much he needs to be the best, not wants, but requires it, just as much as we regular folk need air to breathe?

Cristiano Ronaldo celebrates a goal for Portugal vs Uzbekistan at the 2026 World Cup

Ronaldo got his ninth and 10th career World Cup goals vs Uzbekistan. (Image credit: Getty Images)

Whatever the answer, maybe the real answer lies in our inability to find a concrete one at all.

Maybe it's the fascinating, unexplainable allure of a man who stood under the brightest of lights, demanding our collective attention.

That even though he existed at a point in time where another man, one who possessed even greater gifts, was performing at a higher level, he still forced his way into the debate regardless.

That at 41, he still cries when he fails to secure silverware: a billionaire that's won it all, playing like he's broke and without a trophy to his name.

That for all of Messi's greatness, the more fascinating question actually lies in how Ronaldo was ever able to even challenge him in the debate for being the world's best, and football's greatest.

Cristiano Ronaldo walking with his head down.

Cristiano Ronaldo will not win the 2026 World Cup, and his story will end. (Image credit: Getty Images)

The Argentine is, without a shadow of a doubt, the best player that we will ever see touch grass in our lifetimes.

But when decades pass by and someone, because it will happen, inevitably takes the crown from Messi, whose story will be remembered with more fascination?

"Messi was an alien, son, my own father told me all about him.

"But have you heard about the man who cried tears of sadness when his own team-mates scored?"

Kedar Bayley
Freelance Writer

Kedar Bayley is a trained journalist specialising in culture reporting. As a fan of Liverpool FC, he writes on the Reds often. Knowledgable about all things sports, cinema and television, you can find his words in Screen International, FourFourTwo, Manchester Evening News and more.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.