Louis van Gaal's men appeared to be staring defeat in the face during their last 16 clash on Sunday, as Giovani Dos Santos gave the Central American nation a deserved lead just after the break.
But, the Dutch fought back and dominated the majority of the second half, drawing level in the 88th minute thanks to Wesley Sneijder.
Huntelaar eventually netted the all-important second goal, converting a penalty with admirable composure in the fourth minute of stoppage time, but the Schalke man was in two minds before taking the kick.
The 30-year-old had missed four of his previous five spot-kicks and he acknowledged that he almost changed his mind about taking the penalty.
"I didn't have the balls to shoot him through the middle," he told NIS.
"Arjen had the ball and asked 'would you like to take it?' When I was there I thought about changing (my mind), as I had missed the last time.
"(But) what an adrenaline rush. This is the best drug out there."
Robin van Persie endured a disappointing day individually as he was hauled off for Huntelaar in the second half and he recognised that the excessive heat and humidity made conditions tough.
"It was very tough," the Manchester United forward added.
"When you are losing you want to attack, but you also need to make sure the spaces at the back are not too great. Then the heat, it made it extra hard.
"We now have to deal with in the next round. We are good, I believe in us and that we must continue to do so (believing in themselves)."
Get the best features, fun and footballing frolics straight to your inbox every week.
Thank you for signing up to Four Four Two. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.