Everton manager Roberto Martinez told his team they needed to develop a "nasty streak" to start turning performances into results.
The Spaniard saw his side held 1-1 by Norwich City on Saturday for what was their eighth draw in 16 Premier League games this season.
Everton were wasteful at Carrow Road and the third consecutive draw sees them sitting 10th in the table.
Martinez said his side needed to learn how to make sure their good displays resulted in points.
"You need to have that nasty streak in your own box when sometimes we are still thinking about trying to score the next goal and being creative on the ball," he said.
"That is what is going to make us a winning team, no two ways about it, but within a game there are certain moments when you need to be ruthless and have a nasty streak in order to keep a clean sheet.
"That is an area at the moment in which we are getting heavily punished."
Wes Hoolahan scrambled in Norwich's equaliser against Everton after a set-piece, with Martinez's men having conceded from a corner to draw with Crystal Palace less than a week prior.
Martinez said set-pieces were a major concern for his team.
"It is a problem at the moment," he said.
"You shouldn’t concede from corners at that ratio. A corner cost us two points on Monday, and we conceded a corner and it cost us two points [against Norwich]."
Get the best features, fun and footballing frolics straight to your inbox every week.
Thank you for signing up to Four Four Two. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.