Skip to main content

Sheffied United denied victory at Aston Villa by goal-line technology failure

Aston Villa v Sheffield United – Premier League – Villa Park
(Image credit: Paul Ellis/NMC Pool)

Sheffield United were denied victory at Aston Villa by a technical fault as the Premier League resumed with huge controversy.

The Blades were forced to settle for a 0-0 draw after goal-line technology failed on Wednesday, in the top flight’s first game for three months after the coronavirus pandemic halted sport.

Goalkeeper Orjan Nyland carried Oliver Norwood’s free kick across the line but a goal was not awarded.

Referee Michael Oliver’s watch did not signal a goal and play continued with the video assistant referee failing to intervene.

Victory would have taken Sheffield United into the top five and the Blades will have to wait to see how much the error will cost them in the race for Europe.

They struggled to impose themselves at an empty Villa Park though and Dean Henderson denied John McGinn, with Keinan Davis heading a fine first-half chance over as Villa missed the chance to climb out of the relegation zone.

Dean Smith’s side remain second bottom and a point from safety but, after dominating for long spells, will considering it a huge missed chance in their basement battle.

Every player and official took a knee before kicking off in a huge and striking show of support to the Black Lives Matter movement.

Players took a knee

Players took a knee (PA)

It was a poignant image, which came after a moment of silence for coronavirus victims.

Once the game began, Conor Hourihane tested Henderson after five minutes and Davies – making his first league start of the season – headed over from close range.

Villa, desperately needing points after one win from their last seven games, were the better team but relied on a huge slice of fortune three minutes before the break.

The Blades had barely threatened as they struggled to get into their stride after their enforced three-month break but should have gone ahead.

Referee Michael Oliver points to his watch to signal the goal line technology did not give a goal

Referee Michael Oliver points to his watch to signal the goal line technology did not give a goal (PA)

Norwood swung in a deep free kick from the left and as Nyland went to catch it, team-mate Davis bundled him in.

The goalkeeper clearly carried the ball across the line but referee Oliver waved away United’s claims, indicating his watch had not gone off.

The technology failed for the first time since it was introduced in the Premier League in 2013.

A statement from Hawk-eye Innovations, who run the technology, after the match read: “During the first half of Aston Villa v Sheffield United match at Villa Park, there was a goal line incident where the ball was carried over the line by Aston Villa goalkeeper, No. 25 Nyland.

“The match officials did not receive a signal to the watch nor earpiece as per the Goal Decision System (GDS) protocol. The seven cameras located in the stands around the goal area were significantly occluded by the goalkeeper, defender, and goalpost. This level of occlusion has never been seen before in over 9,000 matches that the Hawk-Eye Goal Line Technology system has been in operation.

“The system was tested and proved functional prior to the start of the match in accordance with the IFAB Laws of The Game and confirmed as working by the match officials. The system has remained functional throughout. Hawk-Eye unreservedly apologises to the Premier League, Sheffield United, and everyone affected by this incident.”

VAR did not intervene as play continued and Villa won a free kick, starting a new passage of play – although it could have checked in the interim period.

Villa tried to take their reprieve and pressed a lacklustre Blades after the break.

Davis just missed Anwar El Ghazi’s low cross and Henderson turned McGinn’s curling effort wide on the hour.

The hosts, who welcome Chelsea on Sunday, had energy but – as so often this season – lacked the killer touch.

And they escaped when Oli McBurnie headed at Nyland with 20 minutes left after Villa almost played themselves into trouble before conceding a corner.

Neither side could find the breakthrough though as the top flight restart ended goalless.