Evander Outguns Messi and Shows Why He's One of the Best Players in MLS

Evander of FC Cincinnati and MLS All-Star controls the ball during the 2025 MLS All-Star Game at Q2 Stadium on July 23, 2025 in Austin, Texas.
Evander of Cincinnati (Image credit: Hector Vivas/MLS via Getty Images)

Wednesday's action in MLS saw plenty of high-scoring affairs and pulsating clashes, from Seattle's 3-3 draw to Colorado to New York Red Bulls' 5-3 victory against New England Revolution.

However, there was zero doubt about what the hottest ticket in the nation was: Inter Miami's trip to Cincinnati. Inter Miami, who just a few months ago appeared to be entering crisis mode under new manager Javier Mascherano, had seemingly turned a corner.

Miami entered the match on the back of five straight MLS victories as well as five straight braces from Lionel Messi.

Lionel Messi #10 of Inter Miami CF controls the ball during the FIFA Club World Cup 2025 group A match between Internacional CF Miami and SE Palmeiras at Hard Rock Stadium on June 23, 2025 in Miami Gardens, Florida.

Messi is considered by many the best footballer of all time (Image credit: Megan Briggs/Getty Images)

This winning streak was interrupted by their participation in the FIFA Club World Cup, which saw them finish second in their group behind Palmeiras before crashing out to PSG in the Round of 16. Miami bounced back in stellar fashion by stringing together comprehensive victories against Montreal, New England and Nashville before traveling to Cincinnati.

The last time these two sides faced off nearly a year ago, Luis Suarez had scored a brace within six minutes to secure a 2-0 win for the Herons. And yet, the spotlight wasn't on Suarez, but Messi and Evander.

DeAndre Yedlin #91 of FC Cincinnati and Max Arfsten #27 of Columbus Crew compete for the ball during the first half of a game at TQL Stadium on September 14, 2024 in Cincinnati, Ohio

Cincinnati are one of the top-ranked teams in MLS (Image credit: Getty Images)

Born in Rio de Janeiro, Evander developed at Vasco da Gama's academy before departing Brazil in 2018 and joining Danish side FC Midtjylland, where he would score 50 goals and 38 assists in 167 appearances, prompting MLS outfit Portland Timbers to acquire him in December 2022.

Signed as a Designated Player, the Brazilian striker made a name for himself in the Pacific Northwest with 26 goals and 22 assists in 61 matches before joining Cincinnati in February in exchange for $12 million and up to $150,000 in conditional performance-based incentives.

It hasn't taken long for him to become an indispensable figure for Cincinnati, filling Luciano Acosta's creative void following the Argentine's departure to Dallas, and emerging as one of the best players of the 2025 MLS season.

Evander entered the match on the back of a hot streak that saw him score in each of his last four matches, a total of eight goal contributions in four. However, it wasn't Evander or Messi who opened the scoring, but Gerardo Valenzuela -- the sole change in Cincy's line-up from their weekend defeat to local rivals Columbus.

FC Cincinnati vs. Inter Miami CF | Full Match Highlights | Evander BRACE vs. Messi! - YouTube FC Cincinnati vs. Inter Miami CF | Full Match Highlights | Evander BRACE vs. Messi! - YouTube
Watch On

Cincy laid on the pressure from start to finish, preventing Miami from making a break for the final third and constricting the game into their opponent's half. Miami were hanging on for dear life -- eventually prompting 39-year-old goalkeeper Oscar Ustari to make way with an injury in the 26th minute.

The hosts opened the scoring in the 16th minute as Luca Orellano zoomed infield before teeing up Valenzuela, who launched his shot into the back of the net. Evander would double the lead in the 50th minute after bouncing the ball into his path with a perfectly measured first touch, riding the contact and cooly squeeze the ball into the back of the net.

Evander put the icing on the cake in the 70th minute after capitalizing on a hapless clearance from backup goalkeeper Rocco Rios Novo and striking the third into an empty net. Whilst Miami were subject to a 3-0 demolition -- their first defeat in MLS since May 18 -- and whilst Messi's magical run came to an end, Cincy strengthened their case as to why they are the team to beat in the East.

Lionel Messi #10 of Inter Miami CF celebrates scoring his team's second goal during the FIFA Club World Cup 2025 group A match between Internacional CF Miami and FC Porto at Mercedes-Benz Stadium on June 19, 2025 in Atlanta, Georgia.

Lionel Messi is a reigning World Cup winner (Image credit: Alex Grimm/Getty Images)

Cincinnati sit second in the Supporters' Shield standings with 45 points, one point behind Philadelphia, one above Nashville, and four above San Diego FC, who are competing in their first-ever MLS season.

As for Miami, they sit fifth in the East, three points behind Columbus, six behind Nashville, and seven behind Cincinnati. Whilst Miami will be looking to come away with a win at the New York Red Bulls, Cincinnati will be traveling to Utah to face Real Salt Lake.

After that, both sides are poised for a tasty rematch in South Florida on July 26, a match that could have pivotal implications not just in the playoff positions, but the Golden Boot race. Evander has climbed to third in the top scorer race with 15 goals, one behind Messi and two behind Nashville's Sam Surridge.

TOPICS

Zach Lowy is a freelance football writer who covers a wide range of football leagues from Serie A to the Premier League to Ligue 1. Fluent in Spanish and Portuguese, Zach has interviewed a wide range of players and ex-players such as Simão Sabrosa, Louis Saha, Andrés Villas-Boas and Diego Forlán. Over the past 6 and a half years, he has served as the co-creator of Breaking The Lines (@BTLVid on Twitter), the chief editor of the website and the main social media producer. Zach has also covered the Portuguese league on a consistent basis, interviewing players from various Primeira Liga clubs like Braga, Rio Ave, Famalicão, Tondela, Estoril Praia and Arouca. He has traveled to Russia and France to cover the World Cup and Toulon Tournament, respectively.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.