The England midfielder was withdrawn after 84 minutes in place of Robbie Keane, just seconds after Mido had equalised for Steve Bruce's side from the penalty spot, inflicting a seventh draw in 10 Premier League games on the Anfield club.
Both Sky Sports pundit Redknapp and BBC sofa-warmer Hansen opined that leaving Gerrard on the pitch would have given Liverpool a far greater chance of pinching all three-points in the few minutes that remained at the JJB Stadium.
"Why take Steven Gerrard off?" slammed Redkanpp. "How many times has he pulled them out of trouble?"
While Rafa's post-match reasoning for taking off his captain - that both he and striker Fernando Torres were tired - didn't wash with ex-Reds captain Hansen.
"Tired? It’s seven minutes to go," he said. "You’re going for the championship and Gerrard is your best player. He’s inspirational. Even if he’s having a stinker in the last couple of games you don’t take him off."
Liverpool take on Chelsea in a crunch top of the table clash at Anfield on Sunday afternoon, and Hansen believes that an away win for Luiz Felipe Scolari's side could signal the end of Liverpool's hunt for a first league crown in 19 years.
"The title race is not over yet but if they are beaten by Chelsea it is," he said.
LIVERPOOL FANS! Check FourFourTwo.com’s ever-expandinginterviews archivefor more stuff to read:
Web Exclusives Ian Rush, Craig Johnston
Q&A Steven Gerrard, Fernando Torres
One on One Michael Owen, Nicolas Anelka, Kevin Keegan
Boy's A Bit Special Danny Guthrie
Ask A Silly Question John Barnes, Peter Crouch, Luis Garcia, John Aldridge
Perfect XI Jamie Carragher
What Happened Next? Julian Dicks
And Another Thing Being a Big Four fan
Plus! Rate Liverpool players (and others) on Talentspotter
Thank you for reading 5 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access
Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription
Join now for unlimited access
Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1