‘He’s failed, and he’s failed in the same way as before’ Former England international calls for Thomas Tuchel sacking with Gareth Southgate nod

MIAMI GARDENS, FLORIDA - JULY 18: Thomas Tuchel, Manager of England, arrives at the stadium before the FIFA World Cup 2026 Bronze Final between France and England at Miami Stadium on July 18, 2026
(Image credit: Getty Images)

Thomas Tuchel’s future as England boss has been the talk of the nation following a disappointing semi-final exit at the hands of Argentina.

The Three Lions had one foot in the final when Anthony Gordon smashed home the opener just shy of the hour mark in that last-four clash.

But Enzo Fernandez’s leveller, followed by a crushing stoppage-time winner from Lautaro Martinez – with Lionel Messi omnipresent throughout – confined England to the dreaded third-place play-off.

Thomas Tuchel compared to Gareth Southgate in BBC pundit rant

ATLANTA, GEORGIA - JULY 15: Thomas Tuchel, Manager of England, looks on before the FIFA World Cup 2026 Semi Final match between England and Argentina at Atlanta Stadium on July 15, 2026

Tuchel was criticised for his defensive approach after taking the lead against Argentina (Image credit: Getty Images)

Much of the criticism levelled at Tuchel surrounded his perceived approach to going a goal up, bringing off goalscorer Gordon for defender Ezri Konsa as his side retreated ever closer to Jordon Pickford.

For former Three Lions international Danny Murphy, it was all too reminiscent of regimes gone by.

LONDON, ENGLAND - OCTOBER 01: Paul Robinson and Danny Murphy are seen working as TV Pundits for the BBC prior to the UEFA Europa League play-off match between Tottenham Hotspur and Maccabi Haifa

Danny Murphy (left) didn't hold back on his evaluation of Tuchel's predicament (Image credit: Getty Images)

“It was a terrible performance second half,” Murphy fumed in the BBC’s pre-match build-up to England’s bronze-medal meeting with France. “I think they went out with a whimper rather than on their shields.”

And there was no doubt in his mind who was responsible, with calls for Tuchel’s sacking following shortly after, despite predicting the German head coach keeping his job.

With what can only have been at least a partial nod to previous incumbent Gareth Southgate – who was similarly criticised for his cautious approach – Murphy made the case for change.

“He’s failed, and he’s failed in the same way we’ve failed before,” the former Liverpool man continued. “It’s the biggest tournament in the world and he had his opportunity, and I think, as I said, I think he probably will get the vote of confidence, but I think we should make a change.

“I think [the players] will be so devastated. They were so close. They had the game in their hands, they had control. They’re missing out on the World Cup final tomorrow because of the tactics.”

MIAMI, FLORIDA - JULY 10: Thomas Tuchel, Manager of England, looks on during an England training session at the Inter Miami CF Training Facility one day ahead of the FIFA World Cup 2026 Quarter Final

Tuchel's current contract takes him until Euro 2028, on home soil. (Image credit: Getty Images)

What FourFourTwo can agree on is that Tuchel will lead England into the next tournament, as right now it’s not clear who’s ready to step into the breach.

Yes, Pep Guardiola is sat with his feet up following his Manchester City departure, with rumours he's been interested in the gig previously, but is he really going to want to jump straight back in? And he’s not immune to overthinking big tournament games himself…

Tuchel got the semi-final wrong, but when the dust settles, we might be better placed to recognise the green shoots from this summer.

Isaac Stacey Stronge
Freelance Writer

Isaac Stacey Stronge is a freelance football writer working for FourFourTwo, Manchester United and Football League World. He has been a season ticket holder at Stockport County throughout the Hatters’ meteoric rise from the National League North to League One and is a die-hard Paddy Madden fan.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.