The FourFourTwo Preview: Cardiff vs Swansea

Billed as

The first ever top-flight South Wales derby (and their first meeting since February 2011).

The lowdown

And so everybody associated with the 18 English top-flight teams collectively ducks as the much-dreaded South Wales derby gets its first outing in the Premier League. Truly, Cardiff vs Swansea is a Hallowe’en tale of fan violence, blood flowing down the M4 and severed heads plopping into the River Taff.


Norwich 0-0 Cardiff (Prem)

Chelsea 4-1 Cardiff (Prem)

Cardiff 1-2 Newcastle (Prem)

Fulham 1-2 Cardiff (Prem)

West Ham 3-2 Cardiff (LC)


Swansea 0-0 West Ham (Prem)

Swansea 1-1 Kuban (EL)

Swansea 4-0 Sunderland (Prem)

So'ton 2-0 Swansea (Prem)

Swansea 1-0 St Gallen (EL)

It’s really not that bad. Yes, there has been trouble in the past. Yes, match-goers are often transported in a police ‘bubble’ (with accompanying helicopter). And yes, the two sets of fans really hate each other, with a passion that makes Newcastle and Sunderland supporters look like grannies squabbling over a lunch bill. 

But things have changed. The Swans have gone continental and the Football League named Cardiff as Family Club of the Year twice in the last three seasons.


Historically it’s an even derby: neither team has won by two or more goals in their last 12 meetings, and neither has ever done the league double over the other across the 28 seasons they've occupied the same division.


Swansea chairman Huw Jenkins has downplayed this meeting’s importance, saying both teams would just rather finish above the other (hardly over-reaching in Swansea’s case), but Angel Rangel has turned up the heat a bit. The Swans right-back has said about Cardiff’s combative £11m signing Gary Medel – yet to be booked this season – that “if you are clever, you can get him sent off” and also that the Bluebirds overpaid “because he’s a holding midfielder, not a goalscorer”. Because if there’s one person you want to rile, it’s 'Loco Boy' Gary Medel.


Passion might be what both teams need. Cardiff were toothless at Norwich and a win would be an almighty boost. Swansea would appreciate a lift after a disappointing stalemate hosting West Ham.

Team news

Ankle-knacked Andreas Cornelius is close to a return for Cardiff (pretty sure we write this every week), although even if he is match fit it would be a brave call by Malky Mackay to give him his first league start in this derby. The Bluebirds have no other injury concerns.


Swansea’s Jonjo Shelvey should return from a hamstring injury to take his place on the bench. No such luck for Ben Davies, still nursing his ankle with frozen peas. Probably.

Players to watch: Ben Turner and Steven Caulker

Even away from home it’s probable that Swansea will dominate possession. Last week they had 67% of the ball (not literally) against West Ham while Cardiff’s opponents, Norwich, had the top eight passers and 20 of the top 22 pass combinations.


As such, and as depressing as it sounds in a home derby, the onus may be on Cardiff to defend and then break. Ben Turner and Steven Caulker are growing as a defensive partnership, wherein Turner handles the clearances (17 against Norwich, 14 in the win over Manchester City) and Caulker the counter-attacks (he started the move for Cardiff’s equaliser against Hull).


Here they’ll have to deal with Michu’s dangerous late runs into the box while also handling Wilfried Bony or Alvaro Vazquez up front. Communication between the centre-back pair will be vital, as will the young Caulker’s concentration levels up against his old team.



Swans 0-1 C'diff (C'ship, Feb 11)

C'diff 0-1 Swans (C'ship, Nov 10)

C'diff 2-1 Swans (C'ship, Apr 10)

Swans 3-2 C'diff (C'ship, Nov 09)

C'diff 2-2 Swans (C'ship, Apr 09)

The managers 

This is Mackay’s first South Wales derby and it’ll be interesting to see how he approaches it, mentally as well as tactically. His predecessor, Dave Jones, used to play down the derby element, even saying it should be treated as any other fixture.


Michael Laudrup gives the impression of being above such nonsense, but he’s also clued into Swansea fans and what they like to see. He’ll ask for an extra 10 percent from his side.


Fun fact: it’s likely that, between them, the managers will start a single Welshman in this match. That’s Neil Taylor; it’ll be one each if Craig Bellamy gets a recall. 

Facts and figures

  • Cardiff goalkeeper David Marshall has made 44 saves this season, 10 more than any other goalkeeper.
  • Swansea have already benefited from two own-goals this season, more than any other side.
  • This will be the 55th league derby between Cardiff and Swansea but the first one played in the English top-flight.
  • That means it will be the first ever English top-flight fixture between non-English clubs.
  • The last meetings between Cardiff and Swansea back in the 2010-11 season saw both games won 1-0 by the side playing away from home.
  • Craig Bellamy is the last player to score a winning goal in a South Wales derby.
  • Swansea have made fewer substitutions than any other Premier League team this season (20).
  • Cardiff have scored a total of only one goal in their last three Premier League home games.
  • Swansea have a league-high four yellow cards for dissent this season.
  • Michu has scored in only three of his last 14 Premier League appearances.

FourFourTwo prediction

Very tough to call, this. We’re going with both teams earning consecutive goalless draws: 0-0.

Cardiff vs Swansea LIVE ANALYSIS with Stats Zone

Thank you for reading 5 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access

Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1

*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription

Join now for unlimited access

Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1

Huw was on the FourFourTwo staff from 2009 to 2015, ultimately as the magazine's Managing Editor, before becoming a freelancer and moving to Wales. As a writer, editor and tragic statto, he still contributes regularly to FFT in print and online, though as a match-going #WalesAway fan, he left a small chunk of his brain on one of many bus journeys across France in 2016.