‘Players are being flogged. If I were Manchester City, I’d declare my entire first team injured and send the youth team to the Club World Cup. I think it’s a joke’ David James warns FIFA over burnout risk

David James
David James is not a fan of the revamped FIFA Club World Cup (Image credit: PA)

FIFA are playing fast and loose with the fitness of the world’s best players ahead of this month’s newly expanded Club World Cup, according to David James.

The expanded tournament which begins next weekend, will feature 32 teams from all corners of the globe compete in the USA over the next month after FIFA abandoned the old format that saw just seven teams take part, with just seven games played in total.

The year’s final will be the 63rd game of the tournament and James has dubbed it ‘a joke’.

David James takes aim at FIFA over Club World Cup burnout

The FIFA Club World Cup trophy during Day 2 of the FIFA Club World Cup Trophy Tour at DAZN Studios on January 23, 2025 in Madrid, Spain

The FIFA Club World Cup trophy (Image credit: Getty Images)

“If I were Manchester City, I would declare my entire first team injured and send the youth team to the Club World Cup,” he told FourFourTwo, speaking on behalf of Prime Casino. “I think it’s a joke. You’ve got the best players and the best teams in the world complaining about too many games, then you introduce this tournament.

“You’re trying to work out who benefits, especially when you look at some of the outfits in it, who – as far as I can consider – haven’t even got a world ranking of the stature to be involved with the best in the world.”

David James in action for England

David James in action for England (Image credit: Press Association)

James - who FourFourTwo ranked at no.5 in the list of the the greatest-ever Premier League goalkeepers - believes the reason for this expanded tournament, which is putting players at risk, is simple: corporate greed.

“The old format was fine,” he continues. “This format just looks like an opportunity for someone to make more money out of players. They’re being flogged for it. It’s not that players shouldn’t be able to go and take part in these matches, but I think it’s an event too far.

“I know there’s some obligation for being in it that you have to put your best team forward, but if players are injured, they’re injured, so declare them injured.

“You’ve got sports science teams looking at recovery periods – if you’re a team like Man City, most of your squad is involved on international duty as well, and what benefit is it to a club when the players that you depend on for nine months of the season are being compromised for one competition?”

Manchester City players celebrate victory on penalties against Manchester United in the Community Shield in August 2024.

James has expressed his concern for his former side Manchester City (Image credit: Getty Images)

“It was FIFA that wanted to change the format, but you’re asking fans to travel around the world to follow their sides. I don’t like it. Because it’s a new format, there will be a lot of opinions similar to mine: that this is never going to work.

“But if it sustains itself and becomes a regular fixture, then in the future we’ll be talking about teams planning on going out there to win it, knowing it’s going to be a highly competitive event. At the moment, though, there will be players who are just absolutely knackered come the start of the season.”

Joe Mewis

For more than a decade, Joe Mewis has worked in football journalism as a reporter and editor. Mewis has had stints at Mirror Football and LeedsLive among others and worked at FourFourTwo throughout Euro 2024, reporting on the tournament. In addition to his journalist work, Mewis is also the author of four football history books that include times on Leeds United and the England national team. Now working as a digital marketing coordinator at Harrogate Town, too, Mewis counts some of his best career moments as being in the iconic Spygate press conference under Marcelo Bielsa and seeing his beloved Leeds lift the Championship trophy during lockdown.

With contributions from