How Barcelona lost Neymar – but retained their greatness

Lionel Messi

Barça suffered a humbling summer – yet now sit five points clear in La Liga and beat Juventus to top spot in their Champions League group. Kiyan Sobhani explains how they’ve done it

We are part of The Trust Project What is it?

Four months have passed since Neymar said goodbye to his team-mates at the Joan Gamper training ground in Barcelona. Though officially still a Blaugrana player at the time, the Braziliam didn’t train – he was excused by manager Ernesto Valverde so as to avoid an awkward session of drills with a player who had mentally checked out.

It wasn’t easy at all to leave Barcelona. I had to think, and rethink, and think again about what I wanted to do

- Neymar

Neymar stopped in, though. He stayed for 30 minutes, made his rounds and took off. Just like that, one of the best players in the world had left Barcelona in an unthinkable manner, through an unlikely process and out of Lionel Messi’s shadow for good – ready to cast his own legacy, and on his own terms. Neymar jumped on a plane to Porto to meet with PSG’s sporting director and doctor. Shortly after, Messi posted his respects on Instagram.

"It was one of the most difficult decisions I’ve made to move," Neymar said upon his arrival in Paris. "It wasn’t easy at all to leave Barcelona. I had to think, and rethink, and think again about what I wanted to do."

With both parties moving on, Barcelona were expected to take a huge hit. They may still, in the long term, but they’ve been surprisingly good in the immediate aftermath of Neymar’s departure – even in the absence of his injured replacement Ousmane Dembele. Here's how...

1. Valverde the rallier

The massive challenge that Valverde faced was collecting together the broken pieces and getting Barça's remaining players to buy into his philosophy amid the turmoil and distractions. He’s proven to be a perfect fit.

Ernesto Valverde

Ernesto Valverde with impressive new signing Nelson Semedo

It’s taken the Spaniard a little time to figure out his starting XI and find a fluid rhythm when it comes to rotations, but he’s starting to hit his stride. For a large stretch of this season, Barcelona were getting results without really looking stable on the pitch. Luis Suarez and Gerard Pique were underperforming, while the team had defensive holes in transition.

Yet 14 games into the domestic calendar, the eye test has gradually started to match results. Over the years, there’s been growing concern among Barcelona circles about a gradual loss of identity in the post-Pep era. Each season that passes, a layer of paint from Guardiola’s project gets peeled off.

Valverde is a man who brings calm everywhere he goes, naturally commanding respect with his coaching style

Yet people forget where Valverde’s roots are. He’s not a Johan Cruyff disciple in the traditional sense, but his footballing beliefs are very much in line with what Barcelona preach historically. Cruyff himself had praised Valverde’s intelligence – and the great Dutchman hardly dished out such pleasantries loosely. Valverde brings calm everywhere he goes, and naturally commands respect with his coaching style. That intelligence shows on the pitch, and Barcelona are starting to see the fruits of his philosophy now.

Against Valencia at the end of November, Barcelona didn’t let Marcelino’s men breathe in the first half. They masked the absence of Gerard Pique with dominant possession and an efficient counter-press. Valencia are a superb counter-attacking team, but they looked frazzled escaping their own third.

Lionel Messi Valencia

Who needs team-mates anyway?

In rare moments that los Che snaffled possession, they lost it almost immediately while Barcelona’s players were in perfect position to swarm in numbers. It unnerved the Mestalla masses. Even when Valencia escaped on the counter, they were making bad decisions – clearly affected by Barcelona’s strategy both tactically and mentally.

Earlier in the season, a similar thing happened against Atletico Madrid at the Wanda Metropolitano too – although it will be interesting to see how Valverde will deal with tougher tests in coming months. In the second half of the 1-1 draw at the Mestalla, Valencia’s adrenaline forced Barcelona to make defensive mistakes. Efficient teams will punish the Catalans eventually, and those that are good enough in attack – especially in transition – will have plenty of opportunities to exploit.

2. Quality in numbers

Last season, with three key players playing overseas during international breaks – Leo Messi, Luis Suarez, Neymar – Barça struggled to tread water while those players rested

Last year, Barcelona’s depth was widely perceived to be better than it really was. Paco Alcacer wasn’t trusted by Luis Enrique, while Andre Gomes was a huge drop-off from Andres Iniesta and Ivan Rakitic. When the team rotated, they suffered, and with three key players playing overseas during international breaks – Leo Messi, Luis Suarez, Neymar – Barça struggled to tread water while those players rested.

This year, the depth has pleasantly surprised Barcelona fans. Midfielder Denis Suarez has taken a leap and connects well with Lionel Messi; new full-back Nelson Semedo has generally looked strong too, despite struggling against Valencia's Portuguese sensation Goncalo Guedes at the Mestalla. Both Semedo and Denis Suarez are yet to feature consistently under Valverde, but have contributed important minutes to this season.

Paco Alcacer

Paco Alcacer's double against Sevilla proved decisive in a 2-1 win

Meanwhile, running joke Gerard Deulofeu has given nobody any reason to chuckle this season. The ex-Toffee may never be your go-to man in a big game, but he can provide quality as a rotational piece.

Now, remember Paco Alcacer, one of Spain’s most promising strikers two years ago who vanished under Luis Enrique? Valverde has resurrected him, providing the young forward with more minutes and allowing him to contribute offensively both off the bench and as a starter. Last season, Alcacer played just 849 minutes. This season he’s already cracked 270, scored a couple of big goals and provided an assist.

The player benefiting most from Neymar's absence is...