Skip to main content

Manchester United v Tottenham: Pochettino measuring up well to old elite

Jose Mourinho might have allowed himself a wry smile when West Ham completed an improbable 3-2 EFL Cup comeback to sink Tottenham at Wembley on Wednesday.

Mourinho's Manchester United host Mauricio Pochettino and Spurs in this weekend's standout fixture - a battle of second versus third, of 20 points apiece in an already intriguing battle for Premier League glory and of grizzled elite tactician against continually rising star.

Each selection call and tactical tweak has seemed to unerringly hit the mark for the Tottenham boss of late - from prompting raised eyebrows by thrusting Fernando Llorente into the starting line-up for last week's 1-1 draw at Real Madrid, to replacing the Spanish target man with Son Heung-min for the tirelessly waspish South Korea forward to wreak havoc in the 4-1 thrashing of Liverpool.

Pochettino's rueful but warm grin when embracing West Ham boss Slaven Bilic at full-time contrasted sharply with Mourinho's terse irritability after United's bore draw at Liverpool and stunning loss at Huddersfield Town over the past two weekends.

Since his arrival at White Hart Lane for the 2014-15 season, Pochettino has claimed 240 points from 123 Premier League games. Only Chelsea – champions in two of the three completed seasons - and current leaders Manchester City have more.

The idealism immediately following Alex Ferguson's glorious reign, when David Moyes was granted a six-year contract on the basis of his own presumed potential and a board keen to do things "the United Way", evaporated as the ignominy of a seventh-place finish festered.

When United appointed the veteran Van Gaal in 2014, Tottenham entrusted Pochettino with the time to build and mould a squad in his own image. All the same promises that soothed Moyes came without the unrelenting scrutiny under which he buckled.

While many have argued over whether the modern United conform to an expected footballing identity, Pochettino has gone about fashioning an ever-improving Tottenham side that is unquestionably his own.

United's recent wobble reopened questions over whether Mourinho still has the capacity for something more than the quick fix of an early trophy or two. Can he build something stable and enduring, or must these later chapters of his career bounce between success and confrontation until employers tire of the repetition?

Pochettino, his Spurs masterpiece close to being fully formed, had an untimely reminder last time out that opportunities to claim the silverware Mourinho has amassed slip away far more easily than they are grasped.

Nevertheless, former Paris Saint-Germain captain Pochettino will probably not need to bat his eyelashes the next time that job comes up as Mourinho did this week. As he heads for the top of the game, United might come to regret playing it safe and not taking a chance.