Their meeting at the Royal Bafokeng Stadium on June 12 will come nearly 60 years after England, taking part in the World Cup for the first time, lost 1-0 to a ragbag American team in Belo Horizonte in the 1950 World Cup finals in Brazil.
For very different reasons, five times champions Brazil would also like to right the wrongs they suffered against Portugal in 1966 when they lost a tempestuous match 3-1 at Goodison Park in England and had Pele hacked so badly he limped off the field as Brazil lost their world title.
England and Brazil are not the only countries who would like to avenge previous heavy World Cup defeats next year after being grouped with old foes in Friday's draw.
Greece, who were crushed 4-0 by Argentina in the 1994 World Cup, would like to turn the tables on their South American opponents in Group B.
BIGGEST UPSET
Nearly 60 years on, though, England's defeat in 1950 - along with Italy's loss to North Korea in 1966 - ranks as the biggest upset the tournament has produced.
The match demolished England's belief that they were still masters of the game they gave to the world and would win the World Cup just by turning up.
England's Italian coach Fabio Capello was not asked about the upset but U.S. coach Bob Bradley said it was a game still talked about back home.
"I did not think about it immediately the draw was made, but it is a game that still resonates with American fans and eventually questions will be asked about it.
"However, the real significance for me and the players is playing England today. 1950 was a long time ago but it would be nice to get the same result as we did then."
