"We've changed our mind..." The players clubs brought back after they'd got rid

Chelsea fans who keep a close eye on other leagues around Europe can be forgiven for finding it somewhat excruciating: in January 2011, the Blues sold Nemanja Matic for £5 million and a part-ex on David Luiz – and have since watched him blossom into a top-class midfielder at Benfica. Now they’re grabbing him back for around £22m – which looks like a song for an individual of his calibre, but can be mathematically confirmed as a lot more than zero. It’s hardly a unique error, mind: FourFourTwo revisits the other rejects that their original clubs went back to pay a pretty penny for…

Alan Shearer

Newcastle-born, Newcastle-bred and Newcastle-mad, the young imp who would become the Premier League’s highest ever scorer was rejected at his Toon trial – insanely, they played him in goal as they were after a net-minder at the time – and instead was spotted by a grateful Southampton scout with a large petrol budget playing for Wallsend Boys Club. After an avalanche of net-busters for Saints and title-winning Blackburn Rovers, his hometown finally came knocking again, with a world-record breaking £15m deal led by fellow Geordie Messiah Kevin Keegan in 1996.

Cesc Fabregas

Even La Masia’s ruthless genius factory makes bad judgement calls: after bringing Barca-barmy Cesc through the ranks from the age of 10 – during which time he racked up Sombrero-fuls of goals – the Catalans didn’t rate Fabregas highly enough to think that he’d be for the first team fodder, instead allowing him to sneak off to the Arsenal academy, where the rest would be history. The 2011 buyback of the midfield maestro would punish the Spaniards’ candle-lit abacus meddlers to the tune of £35m.


The most-capped player in Brazil history and the only man ever to have appeared in three World Cup finals wasn’t fancied much by his local side Palmeiras as a favela teen, and had to wait until the age of 18 before getting snapped up by Sao Paulo instead. But the Alviverde eventually saw the error of their ways and shelled out for the right-back in 1996. Cafu spent a season there before moving to Roma, where he was nicknamed “The Train” for his relentless consistency (clearly oblivious of the existence of South West Trains).

Alvaro Arbeloa

The lofty full-back represented Real Madrid C (yes, there is such a thing) and Real Madrid B in the early-to-mid 2000s, but found breaking into the A Team a bigger ask. “There were eight defenders in the squad, something had to give,” he sighed, after playing just twice for the seniors and moving to Deportivo La Coruna. But after a term there and two with Liverpool, Los Blancos realised that they had misjudged him, and bought back their versatile stopper for £3.5m. He’s now virtually ever-present.

Peter Crouch

Crouchy took the long way round in playing for Spurs, the side he signed professional forms with as a youth in 1998. Without a senior appearance to his name, he left and turned out for Dulwich Hamlet, IFK Hasseleholm, QPR, Portsmouth, Aston Villa, Norwich, Southampton, Liverpool and Portsmouth again, before finally pulling on a first team Tottenham shirt in 2009, having being purchased for £10m by Harry Redknapp.

Sebastian Giovinco

Currently being “monitored” by Arsenal (whatever that means) tiny Turin-born schemer Giovinco, who is marvellously-monikered Atomic Ant (Formica Atomica), has been engaged in a curious tug-of-love with Juventus for his whole career. After coming through their youth system he was loaned to Empoli and then Parma after only playing sporadically for the Old Lady. Parma soon exercised their right to own 50 per cent of the player (€3m), where he played like a trequartista possessed, leading President Tommasso Ghirardi to bluster that he was worth 10 times the amount. Juve then stumped up €11m to buy the 50 per cent back – enough to bring him home. Half mad.

Marco Reus

Another one who snuck through his birthplace’s youth system and had to go elsewhere to prove himself: Reus, now arguably Borussia Dortmund’s finest player, wasn’t fancied as a youngster and instead went to kick around in the 3. Liga with Rot Weiss Ahlen. Winning a transfer to Borussia Monchengladbach as a result of his neat wing play and neater haircut, he eventually ended up heading back to his BVB roots with a €17m deal in 2012.

Leighton Baines

The diminutive Scouse left-back was released twice by Everton – at 12 he was let go from the club along with Joey Barton and Phil Jagielka. “It was a massive blow,” said Baines, who has admitted that he struggled with confidence later in his career as a result. Rejected, he dabbled in Sunday league football instead until the age of 15 – before Wolves and Wigan both offered him lifelines. The mistake would eventually cost Everton’s calculator-crunchers £6m in July 2007.

Thank you for reading 5 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access

Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1

*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription

Join now for unlimited access

Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1