Premier League appearance record could be broken following a contract extension: report

John Carew celebrates with Gareth Barry after scoring for Aston Villa against West Brom in September 2008.
John Carew celebrates with Gareth Barry after scoring for Aston Villa against West Brom in September 2008. (Image credit: Getty Images)

The Premier League has seen an array of footballing veterans throughout its 31 seasons.

Gareth Barry currently holds the record for the most Premier League appearances, but one club is set to give a contract extension to a player who could break Barry’s record.

Some players like Ryan Giggs and Jamie Carragher have made over 500 appearances in the league for just one club – Manchester United and Liverpool, respectively. Others, such as Emile Heskey and David James, have several clubs to thank for their impressive appearance counts.

James Milner could be set to break the Premier League record

James Milner in action for Liverpool against Porto, 2019

James Milner in action for Liverpool (Image credit: Alamy)

Brighton and Hove Albion have begun talks with James Milner over extending his stay at the seaside club, according to The Athletic.

Milner, 39, currently has 637 Premier League appearances, meaning he needs just 16 more to equal Barry’s impressive total of 653 – a manageable target should he sign an extension.

Gareth Barry celebrates a goal for Aston Villa against Sunderland with James Milner in November 2005.

Barry and Milner played together at Aston Villa. (Image credit: Getty Images)

Milner has made just 18 appearances for Brighton since joining in the summer of 2023, with injuries hampering his influence. The Englishman joined from Liverpool, where he turned out 230 times in the league, the highest tally he has accumulated at any of the six clubs he has represented in the Premier League.

In November 2002, Milner made his Premier League debut for Leeds United at just 16 years and 309 days. He then went on to play for Newcastle United, Aston Villa and Manchester City before joining Liverpool.

With 55 goals, 86 assists, three Premier League titles, two FA Cups, two League Cups and one Champions League to his name, Milner’s resume is matched by few English footballers in the modern era.

Barry also played for Aston Villa and Manchester City, making over half of his league appearances for Villa and playing alongside Milner for over two seasons.

With Brighton pushing for a European spot in the latter stages of the 2024/25 season, manager Fabian Hurzeler will undoubtedly be keen to have Milner’s European experience in the squad next year.

Milner, who ranked no.31 FourFourTwo's list of the best English midfielders ever, has a contract that is due to end this summer, but a potential option could be a hybrid player-coach role as part of an extension.

Ben is currently studying for his NCTJ qualification with News Associates after graduating from Durham University. He is an avid Liverpool fan, lover of tactics and long-time enthusiast of FourFourTwo’s quizzes. His favourite memories of being a journalist so far include his interview with musician Banners that featured in the Liverpool FC Programme, as well as Jurgen Klopp signing his article for his student newspaper on Klopp’s brilliant tenure at Anfield. When he does play football he plays as a bizarre striker/right-wing/right-back hybrid.