Why Antoine Semenyo is not cup-tied for Manchester City Carabao Cup semi-final vs Newcastle United

MANCHESTER, ENGLAND - JANUARY 10: Antoine Semenyo of Manchester City looks on as he lines up prior to the Emirates FA Cup Third Round match between Manchester City and Exeter City on January 10, 2026 in Manchester, England. (Photo by Lewis Storey/Getty Images)
Antoine Semenyo lines up ahead of his Manchester City debut (Image credit: Getty Images)

Antoine Semenyo completed a £62.5 million transfer from Bournemouth to Manchester City last week.

The former Cherries talisman was on the scoresheet on his debut in the 10-1 shellacking of Exeter City in the FA Cup Third Round.

Why is Antoine Semenyo not cup-tied vs Newcastle?

MANCHESTER, ENGLAND - JANUARY 10: Antoine Semenyo of Manchester City during the Emirates FA Cup Third Round match between Manchester City and Exeter City on January 10, 2026 in Manchester, England. (Photo by Robbie Jay Barratt - AMA/Getty Images)

Antoine Semenyo on his Manchester City debut (Image credit: Getty Images)

This season, English football's two domestic cup competitions have seen their rules change, permitting players to represent up to two teams during the same campaign.

As a consequence, Semenyo is in contention to feature at St James' Park, to the dismay of Newcastle supporters and their head coach Eddie Howe.

BOURNEMOUTH, ENGLAND - JANUARY 07: Antoine Semenyo of Bournemouth celebrates after scoring a goal to make it 3-2 during the Premier League match between Bournemouth and Tottenham Hotspur at Vitality Stadium on January 07, 2026 in Bournemouth, England. (Photo by Catherine Ivill - AMA/Getty Images)

Antoine Semenyo scored the winner for Bournemouth on his final appearance last week (Image credit: Getty Images)

Semenyo appeared in Bournemouth's Carabao Cup Second Round defeat by Brentford back in August, which in seasons past would have made him ineligible to represent Manchester City in the same competition upon signing for the club.

The EFL's Rule 6.4 states: "A Registered Player shall be permitted to play for up to two Clubs (or clubs) in the Competition in any one Season where such Player has appeared for his parent or loan Club in the Competition prior to the closure of the Winter Transfer Window or the first leg of the Semi - Final (whichever is sooner) and has either been recalled by the parent Club or subsequently moved to a different Club on a Temporary Loan Transfer (or Temporary Transfer where a Premier League Club) or permanent Transfer prior to the closure of the Winter Transfer Window, or the first leg of the Semi - Final (whichever is sooner)."

In layman's terms, this means that Semenyo is eligible to face Newcastle on Tuesday night and in the return leg at the Etihad Stadium, because he has joined Pep Guardiola's side during the winter transfer period, but crucially before the first leg of the semi-final.

"Yeah, it was nice to find out that rule had changed after finding out they'd signed him," Newcastle boss Howe said on Monday.

"I have to say that's one rule change I probably wouldn't be supportive of at this current moment.

Get premium Manchester City tickets HERE with Seat Unique!

Get premium Manchester City tickets HERE with Seat Unique!

Manchester City's hospitality provides Level 2 South West Corner seating and access to the exclusive Manager's Corner Lounge and Bar. Guests can enjoy premium food and bar options, complimentary tea and coffee at half-time and full-time, and a matchday programme. Car parking (one per four guests) is also included, adding convenience to this enhanced match experience.

"But Antoine's had an incredible season. I'm a big admirer of his and he scored on his debut, so fair play to him. I think Man City have signed a very, very good player."

Semenyo's new manager Guardiola sung the forward's praises following his arrival at the Etihad stadium.

"He was extraordinary in Bournemouth and he can play both sides, right, left.

"He knows the Premier League so many clubs want him and he decide to join us.

"He is a perfect age, 25, 26 - the best years are to come."

Joe Donnohue
Senior Digital Writer

Joe joined FourFourTwo as senior digital writer in July 2025 after five years covering Leeds United in the Championship and Premier League. Joe's 'Mastermind' specialist subject is 2000s-era Newcastle United having had a season ticket at St. James' Park for 10 years before relocating to Leeds and later London. Joe takes a keen interest in youth football, covering PL2, U21 Euros, as well as U20 and U17 World Cups in the past, in addition to hosting the industry-leading football recruitment-focused SCOUTED podcast. He is also one of the lucky few to have 'hit top bins' as a contestant on Soccer AM. It wasn't a shin-roller.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.