Skip to main content
Join The Club
- Join our community
Live Q&A Sessions
Weekly interactive sessions
Member Competitions
Win exclusive prizes
Exclusive Content
Premium articles & videos
Early Access
First to see new features
Exclusive Newsletters
Football news direct to your inbox
Monthly Rewards
Surprise gifts & perks
GET CLUB ACCESS QUICK
For the quickest way to join, simply enter your email below and get access. We will send a confirmation and sign you up to our newsletter to keep you updated on all your football news.
By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.
FIND OUT ABOUT OUR MAGAZINE
Want to subscribe to the magazine? Click the button below to find out more information.
Find out more
Get Club Access Quick

Join The Club for quick access. Enter your email below and we'll send confirmation plus sign you up to our newsletter.

By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

Welcome to Fourfourtwo club !
Hi ,

Your membership journey starts here.

Keep exploring and earning more as a member.

MY ACCOUNT

Earn your first badge
Complete 1 quiz to unlock your first badge.
Keep earning badges
Explore ways to get more involved as a member.
Football Quizzes

Football Quizzes

Quick quizzes for football fans.

Read Now
Football Crosswords

Football Crosswords

Football-themed crossword challenges.

Read Now

See what you’ve unlocked.

Explore your membership benefits.

Explore

442Goals

Play the viral 442GOALS game and build an XI of Premier League legends!

Explore
Sign Out
Main navigation menu
FourFourTwo FOOTBALL NEWS, FEATURES, QUIZZES
UK EditionUK AU EditionAustralia US EditionUS CA EditionCanada KR Edition대한민국 TR EditionTürkiye
Subscribe
Sign in
  • View Profile
  • Sign out
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Features
  • Quizzes
  • Clubs
  • Video
  • Newsletter
  • Membership
  • More
    • Interviews
    • Opinion
    • The Magazine Archive
    • Subscribe
    • How to Watch
    • About
    • Lists
Trending
  • 🤩 Play 442GOALS
  • 📺 How to watch the EPL in 2026/27
  • 📆 Football fixtures: Every game in every competition
  • 🎤 Interviews
  • 🇵🇹 Ronaldo
  • 🇦🇷 Messi
  • 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 EPL
  • 🤝 Transfers
  1. Competition
  2. Premier League

Player ratings: Manchester United 1 - 2 Manchester City

Features
By Seb Stafford-Bloor
Published 10 December 2017

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

Manchester United 1 Manchester City 2

Manchester United 1 Manchester City 2

Manchester City prevailed at a snowy Old Trafford, with goals from David Silva and Nicolas Otamendi either side of a fine Marcus Rashford finish.

Page 1 of 30
Page 1 of 30
David De Gea

David De Gea

Produced his best to deny Sane late in the first-half, but was left helpless when Silva scored from the resulting corner. Made a brilliant save from De Bruyne to prevent City taking a 3-1 lead. FFT rating: 7.

Page 2 of 30
Page 2 of 30
Antonio Valencia

Antonio Valencia

Struggled to make any impression in an attacking sense and had difficulty with City’s movement on his side of the pitch. FFT rating: 6.

Page 3 of 30
Page 3 of 30
Chris Smalling

Chris Smalling

Hardly calamitous, but must share the responsibility for United’s lack of organisation at defensive set-pieces. Not helped by the injury to Rojo. FFT rating: 6.

Page 4 of 30
Page 4 of 30
Marcos Rojo

Marcos Rojo

Embarrassed early by Jesus and replaced at half-time following a nasty clash of heads. FFT rating: 6.

Page 5 of 30
Page 5 of 30
Ashley Young

Ashley Young

Coped better with Sane than most full-backs have this season, but struggled to make an impression beyond the halfway line. FFT rating: 6.

Page 6 of 30
Page 6 of 30
Nemanja Matic

Nemanja Matic

Extremely fortunate not to give away a first-half penalty after dragging Otamendi to the ground and struggled to restrict City’s flow of possession throughout. FFT rating 6.

Page 7 of 30
Page 7 of 30
Ander Herrera

Ander Herrera

Picked in Paul Pogba’s absence, presumably with a brief to be the spanner in City’s works. Did little of note beyond a preposterous dive (for which he was rightly cautioned). Replaced by Mata. FFT rating: 5.

Page 8 of 30
Page 8 of 30
Anthony Martial

Anthony Martial

Given his frequent influence from the bench, a very disappointing start. Got nothing from Walker and fed off scraps. FFT rating: 5.

Page 9 of 30
Page 9 of 30
Marcus Rashford

Marcus Rashford

Did little of any consequence before Delph’s misjudgement allowed him in on goal. Finished expertly to level the game, but then faded out of it again after half-time. FFT rating: 7.

Page 10 of 30
Page 10 of 30
Jesse Lingard

Jesse Lingard

Decent, but without ever threatening to make the same impression he did against Arsenal. Withdrawn for Ibrahimovic on 75 minutes. FFT rating: 6.

Page 11 of 30
Page 11 of 30
Romelu Lukaku

Romelu Lukaku

Played almost no part in the first-half, other than to inadvertently assist Silva for the opening goal. A bad day got worse ten minutes into the second half, when his attempted clearance ricocheted to Otamendi for City’s second. A disaster. FFT rating: 4.

Page 12 of 30
Page 12 of 30
Sub: Victor Lindelof

Sub: Victor Lindelof

Replaced Rojo at half-time and was actually the more reliable of the two. FFT rating: 6.

Page 13 of 30
Page 13 of 30
Sub: Zlatan Ibrahimovic

Sub: Zlatan Ibrahimovic

Replaced Lingard for the final fifteen minutes and had little time to make an impression. Might have come on sooner. FFT rating: 5.

Page 14 of 30
Page 14 of 30
Jose Mourinho

Jose Mourinho

Was certainly more adventurous than expected, but his selection failed to slow down Manchester City's midfield. Was probably too late in introducing Ibrahimovic, too. FFT rating: 5.

Page 15 of 30
Page 15 of 30
Ederson

Ederson

The usual balance of timely sweeping and reliable handling. Got his angles slightly wrong for Rashford’s goal, but made up for that with a terrific double save late in the second-half. FFT rating: 8.

Page 16 of 30
Page 16 of 30
Kyle Walker

Kyle Walker

Defended resiliently and used his pace well to keep Martial in front of him. One of his better big game performances without the ball. FFT rating: 7.

Page 17 of 30
Page 17 of 30
Vincent Kompany

Vincent Kompany

Steady enough in the first forty-five minutes, but left the game injured at half-time. FFT rating: 6.

Page 18 of 30
Page 18 of 30
Nicolas Otamendi

Nicolas Otamendi

Had a share in the blame for Manchester United’s equaliser, but returned to par with a fine instinctive finish to put City back in the lead. FFT rating: 7.

Page 19 of 30
Page 19 of 30
Fabian Delph

Fabian Delph

Guilty of a dreadful error which allowed Rashford to equalise and very nearly gifted United a second with another slip. Looked nervous. FFT rating: 5.

Page 20 of 30
Page 20 of 30
Fernandinho

Fernandinho

The base of a City midfield which controlled possession and initially locked United inside their own half. Moved to centre-back following the injury to Kompany, then back again after Mangala entered. Solid. FFT rating: 7.

Page 21 of 30
Page 21 of 30
Kevin De Bruyne

Kevin De Bruyne

Started from deep, picking up the ball in all sorts of positions and looked the most threatening of City’s midfielders. Drew one superb save from De Gea: FFT rating: 7.

Page 22 of 30
Page 22 of 30
Raheem Sterling

Raheem Sterling

Began the game with a few wriggles into the United box and by linking well with Jesus. Faded as an attacking presence as the match wore on, but still contributed without the ball. FFT rating: 7.

Page 23 of 30
Page 23 of 30
David Silva

David Silva

Certainly not his most flamboyant performance, but was in the right place at the right time to prod City into the lead. Became more important as the game progressed, using the ball intelligently as City chewed the clock down. FFT rating: 7.

Page 24 of 30
Page 24 of 30
Leroy Sane

Leroy Sane

Began, unusually, from the right side of City’s attack and was generally quite peripheral. Neat and tidy at all time, but few pyrotechnics. FFT rating: 6.

Page 25 of 30
Page 25 of 30
Gabriel Jesus

Gabriel Jesus

Started the game extremely well, with one slaloming run in particular knotting up Marcos Rojo. Threatened, but never received the chance he was chasing. Subbed for Mangala after an hour. FFT rating: 6.

Page 26 of 30
Page 26 of 30
Sub: Ilkay Gundogan

Sub: Ilkay Gundogan

Brought on at half-time for the stricken Kompany and with no disruption to City's dominance. FFT rating: 6.

Page 27 of 30
Page 27 of 30
Sub: Eliaquim Mangala

Sub: Eliaquim Mangala

Replaced Jesus to allow Fernandinho to move forward back into midfield. Stable. FFT rating: 6.

Page 28 of 30
Page 28 of 30
Sub: Bernardo Silva

Sub: Bernardo Silva

A very late substitute. Still found time to dance through on De Gea's goal, but saw his effort blocked. FFT rating: 5.

Page 29 of 30
Page 29 of 30
Pep Guardiola

Pep Guardiola

Left Sergio Aguero out, but proven right to do so as City benefitted from the extra man in midfield. Timely substitutes also helped subdue United's efforts to get back into the game. FFT rating: 7.

Page 30 of 30
Page 30 of 30
TOPICS
Manchester United Manchester City
Seb Stafford-Bloor

Seb Stafford-Bloor is a football writer at Tifo Football and member of the Football Writers' Association. He was formerly a regularly columnist for the FourFourTwo website, covering all aspects of the game, including tactical analysis, reaction pieces, longer-term trends and critiquing the increasingly shady business of football's financial side and authorities' decision-making.

Read more
Enzo Maresca, head coach of Manchester City, issues instructions during the Premier League 2026/27 match between Manchester United and Manchester City at Old Trafford on September 13, 2026 in Manchester, England.
Tactic How Manchester City adapted tactically after Phil Foden’s red card against Manchester United
 
 
Bruno Fernandes celebrates scoring Manchester United's second goal with Youri Tielemans (L) during the UEFA Champions League match against Sabah FK at Old Trafford in Manchester, on September 10, 2026
Competition Watch Manchester United vs Manchester City: Live streams
 
 
Sergio Aguero scores for Manchester City against Manchester United in the Premier League in November 2018.
Person Sergio Aguero on his fondness for Manchester derby success
 
 
England's midfielder Phil Foden (L) appeals to Scottish referee Nicholas Walsh (R) during the friendly international football match between England and Japan at Wembley Stadium in London on March 31, 2026.
Player Phil Foden's England future dealt another major blow in Manchester City win at Old Trafford
 
 
NOTTINGHAM, ENGLAND - NOVEMBER 7: Rayan Cherki of Manchester City and Erling Haaland of Manchester City reacts as Liam Delap of Nottingham Forest scores his teams second goal during the Premier League 2026/27 match between Nottingham Forest FC and Manchester City at City Ground on November 7, 2026 in Nottingham, United Kingdom. (Photo by Isaac Parkin/Manchester City FC via Getty Images)
Tactic It’s not the mistakes and it’s not “desire and intensity” Manchester City STILL have a Rodri problem
 
 
Manchester City's Norwegian striker #09 Erling Haaland celebrates
Team HENRY WINTER: Manchester City triumph with a 'pointless' Anfield win - and show they have the character to deal with the noise
 
 
Latest in Competition
Fans walking down Wembley way are seen prior to the Emirates FA Cup Semi Final match between Crystal Palace and Aston Villa at Wembley Stadium on April 26, 2025 in London, England.
Competition England register interest for Nations League finals - but there's a major sticking point
 
 
Joachim Andersen of Denmark is challenged by Erling Haaland of Norway during the UEFA Nations League 2026/27 group phase match at Ullevaal Stadion on September 24, 2026 in Oslo, Norway
Competition How to watch Denmark vs Norway: Live Streams, TV Channels, Team News & Predictions for winner-takes-all Nations League clash
 
 
Vinicius Junior of Brazil looks on during the international friendly match between Japan and Brazil
Competition How to watch Singapore vs Brazil: live stream international friendly for FREE
 
 
Lewis Koumas of Wales is challenged by Nuno Mendes of Portugal during the UEFA Nations League 2026/27 group phase match at Estadio Jose Alvalade on September 24, 2026 in Lisbon, Portugal
Competition How to watch Wales vs Portugal: FREE streams and TV channels
 
 
Troy Parrott of Republic of Ireland looks on during the UEFA Nations League 2026/27 group phase match between Austria and Republic of Ireland at Raiffeisen Arena on November 14, 2026 in Linz, Austria
Competition Watch Republic of Ireland vs Kosovo: Free streams & TV info
 
 
Cody Gakpo of the Netherlands and Kai Havertz of Germany during the UEFA Nations League match between the Netherlands and Germany at Johan Cruijff ArenA in Amsterdam, on September 24, 2026
Competition Watch Germany vs Netherlands: Free streams & TV channels
 
 
Latest in Features
Harvey Elliott in action for Valencia
Person "It's a lot of pressure being the Premier League’s youngest ever player...I have sympathy for Harvey Elliot"
 
 
FFT398.uf_admire.gettyimages_1237015931
Team New Sealand: The former naval fort once had a national team managed by Julian Dicks, now they're relaunching...
 
 
Joachim Andersen of Denmark is challenged by Erling Haaland of Norway during the UEFA Nations League 2026/27 group phase match at Ullevaal Stadion on September 24, 2026 in Oslo, Norway
Competition How to watch Denmark vs Norway: Live Streams, TV Channels, Team News & Predictions for winner-takes-all Nations League clash
 
 
Vinicius Junior of Brazil looks on during the international friendly match between Japan and Brazil
Competition How to watch Singapore vs Brazil: live stream international friendly for FREE
 
 
Lewis Koumas of Wales is challenged by Nuno Mendes of Portugal during the UEFA Nations League 2026/27 group phase match at Estadio Jose Alvalade on September 24, 2026 in Lisbon, Portugal
Competition How to watch Wales vs Portugal: FREE streams and TV channels
 
 
Troy Parrott of Republic of Ireland looks on during the UEFA Nations League 2026/27 group phase match between Austria and Republic of Ireland at Raiffeisen Arena on November 14, 2026 in Linz, Austria
Competition Watch Republic of Ireland vs Kosovo: Free streams & TV info
 
 
LATEST ARTICLES
  1. Manchester City were found guilty of breaking over 100 Premier League rules, and have been
    1
    Manchester City dealt £1.5bn blow over Premier League charges: report
  2. 2
    Who are the two men running against Gianni Infantino in FIFA president election?
  3. 3
    Manchester United’s fitness levels are like that of a Sunday league team - no wonder they appointed Mauricio Pochettino
  4. 4
    Leicester City drop sponsor following row over Russian adult actor
  5. 5
    Arsenal in shock Alex Scott move - with sales needed for transfer: report

FourFourTwo is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

Add as a preferred source on Google Add as a preferred source on Google
  • About FourFourTwo
  • Advertise with us
  • Worldwide
  • Cookies Policy
  • Accessibility statement
  • Careers
  • How to pitch to FourFourTwo

© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.

Please login or signup to comment

Please wait...