Meet the EFL club standing in the way of Italy's World Cup hopes

Davide Frattesi is on Newcastle United's radar
Italy face Northern Ireland in the World Cup play-off semi-final tonight (Image credit: Getty Images)

Northern Ireland are dreaming of reaching their first World Cup in 40 years - and if they get there, it will be an achievement made in the EFL.

Of the 28 players selected by boss Michael O'Neill in his initial squad for tonight's World Cup play-off semi-final away to Italy, 21 currently turn out for clubs in the Championship or League One.

Article continues below

EFL stars aim to cause more World Cup heartbreak for Italy

Michael O'Neill

Northern Ireland boss Michael O'Neill (Image credit: PA Images)

Both Italy and Northern Ireland will feel they are overdue an appearance at the Finals. The Azzurri, who have lifted the trophy four times, have failed to qualify for the past two editions of the tournament, suffering traumatic play-off defeats by Sweden in 2017 and North Macedonia in 2022.

Italy's 12-year wait will seem like nothing to Northern Ireland, whose most recent finals appearance came at the 1986 World Cup in Mexico.

Oxford United midfielder Jamie Donley celebrates his goal against Blackburn Rovers

Oxford United midfielder Jamie Donley celebrates his goal against Blackburn Rovers - who are managed by Northern Ireland boss O'Neill (Image credit: Getty Images)

O'Neill's side are huge underdogs and would still have to beat Wales or Bosnia and Herzegovina away from home in next Tuesday's play-off final to qualify for this summer's tournament in North America.

But if Northern Ireland are to spring a surprise tonight, one EFL club could play a particularly important role.

Championship strugglers Oxford United boast four players in O'Neill's party: right back Brodie Spencer, centre back Ciaron Brown, central midfielder Jamie McDonnell and attacking midfielder Jamie Donley.

McDonnell is reportedly set to miss out on the 23-man matchday squad, but his three U's team-mates are all likely to play a part against Italy.

Tottenham Hotspur loanee Donley started and scored the only goal in Northern Ireland's most recent fixture, a 1-0 win over Luxembourg in November, while Brown could also keep his place in the XI, particularly with Sunderland centre back Dan Ballard and Liverpool full back Conor Bradley missing through injury.

Antrim , United Kingdom - 10 October 2025; Conor Bradley of Northern Ireland during the FIFA World Cup 2026 qualifier match between Northern Ireland and Slovakia at Clearer Twist National Football Stadium at Windsor Park in Belfast. (Photo By Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile via Getty Images)

Northern Ireland captain Conor Bradley is sidelined through injury (Image credit: Getty Images)

The absence of Bradley could put Spencer in contention for a starting spot, after the 21-year-old got the nod for the 1-0 home defeat by Germany in October.

There is an added layer of interest for O'Neill, who has taken temporary charge of Oxford's relegation rivals Blackburn Rovers until the end of the season, alongside his international duties.

The two sides met at the Kassam Stadium in a relegation six-pointer earlier this month and of course it was a Northern Ireland player who popped up with the winning goal, as Donley's strike secured a 1-0 victory for the hosts.

O'Neill will need his Oxford players to produce another big performance tonight - and again on Tuesday, if they progress - while also hoping it does not provide them with extra inspiration for the Championship run-in.

Freelance writer

James Roberts is a freelance sports journalist working for FourFourTwo. He has spent the past three years as a sports sub-editor for various national newspapers and started his career at the Oxford Mail, where he covered Oxford United home and away.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.